Is it possible to drink alcohol in a parked car or will you lose your license for this?

Drinking alcohol while the car is turned off or even running is quite common practice for thousands or even hundreds of thousands of our fellow citizens. Someone drinks a bottle of foam secretly from his wife, while someone has a casual conversation with a friend after a hard day at work. After all, according to the law, you shouldn’t be deprived of your license if you drink in a parked car.

Many drivers, who have never driven a car while intoxicated in their lives, do not hide the fact that it is still nice to drink something cool and with a slight temperature in such a cozy and familiar car on a hot day. But traffic police officers do not share this position and regularly try to prosecute drivers who drink alcohol while sitting in their own car and not even intending to go anywhere.

Will you lose your license if you drink in a stationary car?

The answer to this question will only be given by a specific court that is lucky enough to hear your case on the merits. However, the following receive close attention from traffic police officers:

Drinking alcohol in a running car or a switched off car;
Drinking alcoholic beverages in a car while sitting in the passenger seats;
Drinking beer or other drinks while repairing a car, even if the car is physically unable to move.

Moreover, in any of the above cases, judicial practice knows a lot of negative court decisions for drivers - they were simply deprived of their rights without regard to the circumstances.

Most courts seem to take the position that if the driver drinks inside the car, he could drive further under the influence. It’s better to deprive it just in case, you never know!

Every lawyer understands that such a position is complete absurdity, and, moreover, is not based either on the law or on the judicial practice of the highest courts.
It is because of this hodgepodge of judicial positions that no one will tell you for sure whether you can drink alcohol in a stationary car. Deprivation of a license for drinking alcohol in a car that is not running is one of the few categories of cases where it is possible to avoid deprivation of a license! The main thing is to seek help from a lawyer as soon as possible. Call now and check your chances of success. Consultation is free!

Do you need legal advice or services? Call!
Moscow and region: +7-499-938-44-67

St. Petersburg and region +7-812-425-64-18

Regions throughout Russia: +7-800-3333-762

A lawyer will call you back within 10-15 minutes. Seven days a week!

Is it possible to drink alcohol in a stationary car?

First, we should consider whether there are signs of a violation of the law in the fact that the driver is in the car with a bottle of alcoholic beverage?

In accordance with Article 12.8 of the Code of Administrative Offenses, driving while intoxicated is punishable by a fine and deprivation of a driver's license. That is, two types of punishment are expected to be imposed.

The main feature of the offense being committed is the concept of “control”. Thus, the driver of the vehicle must drive the car, and not just sit in the passenger compartment.

Therefore, the simple presence of the driver in the vehicle does not contain any signs of an administrative offense.

Therefore, we can conclude that the fact of drinking alcohol in a car will not entail administrative punishment for driving while intoxicated.

How should you behave with a traffic police inspector if the driver is drunk in a car that is parked and the inspector approaches him?

There is nothing complicated about this. You just need to follow the included instructions. It should be noted that the content of this article does not encourage anyone to drink alcohol, especially in the cabin of their own car. After all, this drink is not so harmless to human health.

Can your license be revoked if you sit in an unstarted car and drink beer?

Yes. There are plenty of cases of this kind in practice, and despite the fact that this is clearly illegal, most of these cases end in the deprivation of the rights of the person who drank alcohol in the car.

Why is this happening? Experts identify several reasons:

Blind confidence of magistrates in the correctness of traffic police inspectors. The phrase “there is no reason not to trust police officers” has become the talk of the town thanks to tens of thousands of unscrupulous drivers who drove while drunk and then tried to evade responsibility. But what about those who are truly innocent, but their testimony is drowned in a stream of cliched court decisions?
Reluctance to do extra work. In order to “ruin the case,” the judge will have to interview many witnesses, possibly order an examination, justify the inadmissibility of certain evidence, and refute the arguments of the police officers. A lot of cases are decided “according to a template”, deviating from which means wasting a whole day of time, during which 3-4 cases can be considered. It sounds strange, but the human factor has its place.
There is no presumption of correctness of the evidence of the person involved. Any argument, even a multi-hour audio recording from the moment the first bottle is opened until the arrival of the traffic police, is considered an “attempt to evade responsibility.” The traffic police officer is always right, the person involved is always lying - this is how justices of the peace make the vast majority of decisions. Although no, not the overwhelming majority - the absolute majority of 99%.

At the same time, the opinion of any lawyer is obvious - deprivation of rights for drinking beer or other alcohol in a stationary car is illegal. There are no rules prohibiting drinking in a vehicle. Driving a vehicle is not considered driving that vehicle.

This is exactly what one should proceed from when protecting one’s rights, but arguments against the opinion of the traffic police are rarely accepted by the court.

Is it possible to drink beer in a parked car? Lawyer's answer

The law does not prohibit drinking alcohol in a car, either for the passenger or the driver. The law prohibits DRIVING a vehicle while intoxicated.

At the same time, the term “control” will still cause a lot of controversy, since according to the rules of the Road Traffic Regulations, control is considered to be the movement and movement of the car.

Against this background, even a lawyer is unable to give an ironclad answer about whether it is possible to drink beer in a parked car. But we can advise you to adhere to the following rules and algorithm of actions if you decide to drink in your car or become the object of attention of the traffic police at this moment.

Arbitrage practice

Often, being in a car while intoxicated was interpreted in the same way as driving while driving. Many drivers lost their licenses for this reason or had to pay a large fine. Typically, the courts sided with the traffic police and did not cancel the court reports prepared by traffic police officers.

But when considering the motorist’s complaint, the Supreme Court overturned the decision of the traffic police and took into account the appeal in the case of deprivation of rights for drinking alcohol. According to the case file, the inspector found three women drinking alcohol in a car parked in the yard. In the report from the scene of the incident, the inspector indicated that he stopped the car while the drunk car owner was driving it. As a result, the owner was deprived of the right to drive the vehicle for a year and 8 months and was given a fine of 30 thousand rubles.

Two courts sided with the inspector, despite the objections of witnesses. But the Supreme Court took into account that the traffic police officer did not stop the car, but approached the parked car. As a result, all charges against the defendant were dropped.

The Supreme Court made a similar decision in another case from 2015.

What should you do if you lose your license for drinking in a parked car?

So, a typical situation: you are drinking alcohol with your car turned off or on, or even repairing it with a bottle of beer, when a traffic police crew approaches you.

Well, then everything is like in a sad movie: Your documents! Are we drinking? Are we managing? Let's pass.

First of all, ask the employee for his badge number, and at the same time demand to show his identification. Remember or write down all the information from there, as well as the number of his company car. If they want to revoke your license for drinking in a parked car, this information will obviously be useful to you.

Let's start with the documents

IDPS is asked to show documents. What to do? Refusing and disowning everything is not an option; formally, traffic police have the right to ask for documents for the car that confirm your right to use it. In addition, if you refuse to provide documents, you may be charged with disobedience to police officers.

You can:

provide the traffic police officer with a vehicle registration certificate and your passport.
if the car is not registered in your name - a power of attorney.
if there is no power of attorney, you will have to call the owner - otherwise you will not be able to prove the legality of your stay in the car.

Such demands are legal and logical - what if you are a car thief, the traffic police will say, and their suspicion is completely justified.

What not to do:

Do not hand over your driver’s license - after all, you are not driving a car, which you can directly and clearly state to the police;
Do not show your MTPL policy for the same reasons.

But let's return to the issue of drinking alcohol in a parked car.

So, the driver’s actions should be as follows

You should ask the traffic police inspector to present his service ID to verify which service the police officer belongs to;
If you remember poorly, then you should record the details of the employee who approached you by writing in a notebook or taking a photo using a mobile phone or smartphone. This is necessary in order to reliably know who you are dealing with, and in case of an unfavorable development of events, to know who is guilty of violating your rights;
In the event that a police officer ignores your demands to introduce himself, you can safely call a police squad using the short telephone number 02 or 112. It does not matter that you may be intoxicated, if you are confident that you are right, then it is better prevent the development of excess in advance;
If you have a video recorder in your car, then it is advisable to record all communications with the inspector. Or use a smartphone. This will allow you to defend your case and prove your innocence of the charged offense. The inspector should not be aware that filming is taking place;
If you are required to provide documents, you can present a civil passport, which certifies the identity of a citizen of the Russian Federation on the territory of your country, as well as a registration document for the vehicle. Under no circumstances should you take out your driver’s license or show that you even have it with you. After all, you are not driving a car, therefore, you are not required to present a driver’s license. A citizen inside a car is not a driver, since he is not driving the vehicle. And the car registration certificate confirms that it is yours, and you are legally in the vehicle;
If a traffic police inspector confiscates any of the documents you presented, you should immediately notify the police by phone.

Video recording is our best friend

As already written above, the court usually has no reason not to trust the police officers, so if you find yourself alone against two representatives of the traffic police, you will obviously lose. If you suddenly drank alcohol alone or your friend suddenly disappeared, record everything on video.

A video recording of the conversation comes to the rescue.

The best thing is to turn your standard DVR towards the police officer.
If there is no recorder, use your smartphone, or even a camera with a video recording function!

No one guarantees that your video will be included as evidence, but it can be “uploaded” to the world by posting it on social networks and attract public attention if suddenly any abuses are committed by a traffic police officer.

If there is someone else in the car besides you, they can also keep their own record. Just in case, otherwise your copy will be lost.

And most importantly: Do not erase or move the recording from the media under any circumstances! When you insist on including the video as evidence, it is possible that you will be accused of editing it. If it comes to examination, then experts will evaluate only the material from the original media! If the video was copied or “cropped” (to remove, for example, your swearing when you saw police officers outside the car window), then there is no hope of recognizing it as reliable.

This may sound strange, but if you are going to drink beer in a parked car, then to avoid having your license revoked, turn on the video recording. Right up to turning the recorder camera into the cabin, which will record everything - from the opening of the first bottle to the traffic police officer approaching the window. Some may find this funny, but such a video is the only obvious chance to achieve an acquittal, at least on appeal. If you are very embarrassed about yourself and your drunken conversations with a friend, turn off the sound recording. It would be enough. But don’t forget to turn it on when you start communicating with traffic police!

Drink driving claims

In this case, the best defense will be an attack. In a legal and correct sense, of course. Make the inspector upset three times because he decided to “quickly” draw up a report on a lone drunkard sitting in a car.

What can be done from a legal point of view?

Demand that a protocol of your arrest be drawn up (without it you may not even get into the IDPS car);
On all documents that relate to driving a vehicle while drunk (protocol of suspension; protocol of detention of a vehicle), clearly and clearly write that you do not agree with the violation, the car was not driven, it was standing still, there is a video. Follow the strokes of empty spaces in documents to avoid adding fictitious facts.
If a detention report is nevertheless drawn up, pay attention to the absence of witnesses. If witnesses were included, but you did not see them, make a corresponding note on the protocol.
When you are sent for a medical examination (and there will be one!), write in the protocol that you do not agree, did not control, etc. - all the same as mentioned above.
If you are still put in the car, demand a video recording or, again, the involvement of two witnesses.

If you refuse to be examined, you will be deprived of your rights under another article. But in court, in any case, you will have to prove that you were not driving the vehicle. According to the law, however, position employees must prove this, but we, as you remember, “... have no reason to doubt the veracity of their testimony...”. Therefore, you will have to prove that you are right.

How else can you help yourself if your license is revoked for drinking beer in a parked car?

If you are alone, invite your friends, or better yet, a good lawyer or at least an experienced lawyer from among your acquaintances;
Assign everyone to video and audio recording. The more sources there are, the less chance you have of being accused of falsifying evidence;
Consult with lawyers by phone - ask your lawyer a question or contact our specialists. They will tell you how to follow every action of the traffic police inspector when preparing documents.
If you experience aggression or threats from a traffic police officer, lock yourself in the car, turn on the video and call the police hotline or 112. Also ask one of your friends to drive up.
Under no circumstances should you be rude to the police or show hostility. A careless word can significantly add to your problems, because they are still being executed.

What to do in court?

At the court hearing, be sure to ensure your attendance and defend your position. Make sure you hire an experienced attorney or lawyer who knows the process thoroughly and can help you defend yourself.

Key arguments:

The car did not move, you did not control it;
This can be confirmed by witnesses, neighbors, friends, etc.
Request a video recording from the traffic police crew recorder, where details may be visible;
Include your video and the videos of your friends;
Insist on an examination if the court suddenly sees a sign of editing in the video (alas, the examination costs money);
Focus on the lack of evidence of your control of the car, which is an irremovable doubt in your favor.

If the magistrate does not heed your arguments, appeal the decision to the appeal (district or city court), and then to the supervisory authority - to the regional court.

Unsuccessful attempt by traffic police officers to revoke rights for drinking in a stationary car

Background
Are we violating?
A story with unknown control and a lot of characters
Procedure
Lawyer's comment

A real story with step-by-step instructions on what to do if you were drinking in a stationary car, and the traffic police are trying to charge you with driving while intoxicated.

Lawyers received an interesting story from one of the website visitors about how he defended his rights during an illegal attempt by the traffic police to deprive him of the right to drive a car for drinking alcohol in a switched off car. Of course, he owes a lot in this story to a number of happy accidents, but the decisive role in this was played by his self-control and one of our old publications about the procedure for depriving one’s license for drinking in a parked car.

Is it possible to drink alcohol in your car: is it not a public place?

Further - on behalf of our visitor, with some comments and additions.

Background

After a hard day at work, I arrived at my yard and went into my apartment, where I left my bag with documents. As I went outside to park my car in the garage, I met a neighbor who suggested I have some beer. I agreed. The car was parked in a small dead end, facing the blank wall of another house, so we did not “disguise” ourselves. The engine was not started - despite the autumn weather it was still warm. After drinking two bottles of beer, we went to the store, and 10 minutes later a traffic police crew arrived at the car. The neighbor got nervous, and I must admit, I was a little tense - I’ve already heard a lot of stories about how even car enthusiasts who repaired a car that was obviously incapable of movement were deprived of their license. But I remembered an article I had previously read on this site about how to behave, and prepared for an unpleasant conversation. The DVR, by the way, was turned off all this time - I turned it on after the traffic police car had already arrived. And it wasn't very good.

Are we violating?

The inspector approached and introduced himself and asked?

- No, what kind of violation are we talking about?

– Driving while intoxicated.

– Where do you see driving and why did you decide that I was drunk?

“Well, you drink alcohol in a car,” the traffic police officer answered less confidently.

- That's right, I'm drinking. In a stationary, switched off car.

- Show me your documents! - the inspector demanded.

I handed him the vehicle registration certificate, which was always under the visor.

“I can go home to get my passport,” I suggested. – There is xeropokia here, here it is.

“I’d like your driver’s license and insurance, please,” the traffic cop demanded.

- They are at home, and why do you need them?

“The driver is obliged to have them with him and...” the inspector began, but I interrupted him.

- It's the driver! I am not the driver at the moment, I am the owner of the car. I didn’t go anywhere and didn’t intend to, so the documents are in the apartment. And in order to avoid further meaningless conversation, please note that our entire conversation is recorded on a video recorder. Which, by the way, has been running here for 2 hours already and it clearly shows that I wasn’t driving anywhere and didn’t even turn on the engine!

The inspector hesitated. A second colleague came to his aid.

A story with unknown control and a lot of characters

an attempt to revoke your license for drinking in a stationary car - Will we undergo an examination? – the first inspector asked irritably.

- For what?

- Make sure you are not drunk.

- So I’m a little drunk, I don’t hide it. But is it illegal to drink in your car? I haven't heard of such a law. I don’t even drink on the street, on my private property.

- Eyewitnesses reported that after drinking, you drove the car, drank, then drove off somewhere and returned. Their testimony will be included in the file,” the second inspector began to press.

- Let's have eyewitnesses! I also have an eyewitness,” I nodded at my comrade. – And on the window of that house there is a surveillance camera that clearly sees this car and recorded that it has been standing here for two hours!

I was already bluffing about the camera, of course. Although we definitely got caught in one of the private video cameras monitoring the parking lot (and we had a lot of them in our yard!).

“Let’s breathe into the straw and that’s it,” the first inspector said somehow even ingratiatingly.

- No, we’re not breathing. No reason, I'm not a driver. Let my friend breathe then?

“Yes, let’s check me,” the neighbor smiled.

The inspectors looked at each other again. I'm already tired of everything.

- Guys, or already draw up a protocol on the lawlessness, but I will write on each piece of paper how it all happened. I will provide a lot of witnesses - there they are, sitting on the benches, and I will present all the video recordings to the court, and I will additionally publish them on social networks, because you are accusing me of something that I did not do. Or let's end this nonsense already. The police looked at each other and retreated to the official car. After 5 minutes, having called someone, they came up again and again asked for a PTS, then a photocopy of the passport. Then they left. My neighbor and I finished our get-togethers and went to the entrance, and at that moment the district police officer’s Niva drove into the yard. She drove past, stopped near the car and drove on. Apparently they handed it over “according to their jurisdiction” so that the local police officer would try to charge us with drinking in a public place.

Procedure

As you can see, the key role is played by some successful techniques and, apparently, the caution of the inspectors, who were afraid to register such a confident driver. Among them:

Confidence in your innocence. You need to know that the truth is on your side and under no circumstances enter into a “deal” with the traffic police.

It was a lucky coincidence: the traffic police believed in the camera, the DVR. If you drink in the car, it is better to stand in the field of view of a street or neighbor’s camera, and also do not turn off the DVR.

Denial of the fact of control to the last.

Refusal of examination, which indirectly means recognition of the fact of control.

Refusal to hand over documents to MANAGE the car, since there is no control!

If you failed to defend your rights and the police draw up a report, write everywhere, in every document, about your disagreement and about the lack of control of the car. Do not agree to the examination under any circumstances!

Lawyer's comment

The author of the story was really lucky; usually in such situations everything ends with a refusal to undergo a medical examination, and from nowhere the witnesses confirm in their testimony that the driver was driving the car. But a definite plus for legal literacy and self-confidence, which together allowed us to avoid an illegal protocol.

The Supreme Court of Russia allowed drivers to drink in cars with the engine running?

Alas, despite the widespread news in this context, the Supreme Court did not make such decisions. But there was Resolution No. 45-AD15-8 of November 27, 2015, in which a person who was drinking in a faulty car was restored to all rights, since the magistrate did not exclude irreducible doubts, which are interpreted in favor of the accused. In particular, the following were used as evidence:

Information about the vehicle's mileage from the GLONASS system;
Certificates from a car service, in which the car components were under repair;
Certificates from the organization to which the car was assigned (it was official).

Based on the listed body of evidence, the driver who was actually deprived of his license was acquitted, and the case was dismissed due to the lack of proof of the offense. Formally, the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation gave an answer about whether it is possible to drink alcohol in a stationary car - yes, it is possible. No control. But in this case there could be no control due to a technical malfunction.

The best way to clarify the position of the Supreme Court is to still reach it with a corresponding complaint in your case. Who knows, what if you create a precedent? Our lawyers can help you with drawing up all the necessary documents!

However, not everyone is lucky in this regard - with the engine running, there are very, very many chances to lose your rights, but defending your rights in a bunch of instances is long, troublesome and expensive.

I was sitting in the car drinking beer. Deprived of rights. Arbitrage practice

Judicial practice on accusing drivers of drinking alcohol in a parked car is almost clear - almost everyone is deprived of their license.

They are deprived for the following:

The driver was sitting behind the wheel with the car turned off or on and drinking;
The driver drank alcohol even in the passenger seat;
Everyone drank in the car, but they deprive the driver - the owner of the car or sitting in the driver's seat.

It is almost impossible to challenge the arguments of police officers - the judges deprive everyone. Little is known about cases of termination of proceedings in cases of this kind; even with a very strong desire, you will not find them on the Internet.

And in the current situation, it’s really easier not to drink in the car than to seek justice later.