Overtaking by a “locomotive”: how to avoid getting your license revoked

Hello, friends! Today we are talking about overtaking by a train - what is the punishment in the traffic rules, as well as about the features and sanctions for drivers for double overtaking.

It is important to understand that the traffic rules interpret the train and double overtaking differently. These are 2 types of maneuvers, which have one thing in common - driving into the oncoming lane, as well as passing other vehicles.

You need to understand what the traffic rules say, whether such maneuvers can be performed, and how to act correctly. Plus the size of fines for incorrect maneuvers on the part of the overtaking person.

Understanding the concepts

Before you announce the fine for overtaking a train, as well as for double overtaking, you should understand what this means.

Double overtaking is considered to be overtaking 2 or more vehicles by driving into the oncoming lane. That is, during such a maneuver, having gotten ahead of the first car, the driver does not return to his part of the road. Or overtaking a car that is overtaking at that moment is considered as such.

But there is also the concept of being overtaken by a train. Also called gooseneck. In this case, you drive into the oncoming lane behind the car that is overtaking. At this moment, there are 2 or more cars on the opposite side of the road.

There is a whole section in the current traffic regulations regarding overtaking. All the rules for safe maneuvers, existing prohibitions, as well as the conditions under which overtaking is possible are spelled out here.

The punishment does not follow for the fact of overtaking. The question here is about entering someone else's lane.

Yes, in theory, when overtaking you always need to drive into oncoming traffic. But not always, when driving into the oncoming lane, the driver overtakes. Sometimes this is an advance, as in the case of overtaking slow-moving vehicles, which were already discussed earlier.

And overtaking in dangerous turns is always prohibited. There are no conditions that allow such an action to be performed without violating the rules.

Overtaking single file or train

Overtaking in single file or by a train, when several cars are overtaking a vehicle at once, is prohibited, since the vehicle moving in front is overtaking - clause 11.2 of the traffic rules. The logic is clear - cars in front can block the oncoming lane from view, and the driver is not able to comply with the requirements of clause 11.1 of the traffic rules, that is, he is not able to determine whether the oncoming lane is clear at a distance sufficient for overtaking or not.

The subtlety is that clause 11.2 of the traffic rules describes the prohibition of overtaking where visibility is limited by circumstances. And here is the key difference from paragraph 11.4 of the traffic rules, since it prohibits overtaking in areas with limited visibility - see Restricted visibility.

I highlight once again: clause 11.2 – circumstances prohibiting overtaking, clause 11.4 – areas where overtaking is prohibited.

To establish visibility restrictions on a section of the road, special techniques and special devices are used by specially trained people. The result of the work is an objective determination of the fact of visibility restrictions on a given section of the road with the subsequent installation of appropriate signs. It is impossible to challenge overtaking in a place where visibility is limited.

The circumstances of visibility limitation are established subjectively , and it is difficult to establish the certainty of the violation.

You can say it differently. Traffic regulations provide the driver with many rights, for example, the right to determine the number of lanes for traffic in the absence of signs or markings - clause 9.1 of the traffic regulations. Paragraph 11.2 of the traffic rules gives the driver the right to subjectively determine whether overtaking is safe or not if someone in front is already overtaking.

Apparently, this point was taken into account by the Supreme Court in PPVS No. 20. Compare the two wordings yourself - from the SDA and from the PPVS:

“The driver is prohibited from overtaking in cases where the vehicle moving in front is overtaking or going around an obstacle,” - clause 11.2 of the traffic rules.

“It is not allowed to overtake a vehicle moving in front that is overtaking or going around an obstacle,” - paragraph “g”, paragraph 15 of the PPVS No. 20 of June 25, 2019.

It is immediately clear that according to the traffic rules, both overtaking an overtaking person (“double overtaking”) and overtaking “in single file” are prohibited. And according to PPVS - only “double overtaking”. Overtaking an overtaking person is an objective fact, overtaking in single file is a subjective fact. See further Evaluative Concepts.

It is important to understand that clause 11.2 of the traffic rules prohibits single file overtaking of the same vehicle. If there is another truck in front of the truck that you are going to overtake, which your colleague is trying to overtake, then the oncoming lane in front of him is clear at a distance sufficient for overtaking. This is a signal to you that you can overtake - the oncoming lane is clear at a distance sufficient for you to overtake. That is, as mentioned above, you are able to fulfill the requirements of clause 11.1 of the traffic rules, which, by the way, does not say anything that the driver must visually verify whether the oncoming lane is clear or not.

Conclusion: compliance with the requirements of clause 11.2 of the Traffic Regulations should always be considered in conjunction with compliance with the requirements of clause 11.1 of the Traffic Regulations.

It is more correct to refuse to overtake in single file not because of limited visibility, but because the driver becomes dependent on other drivers who are overtaking ahead or behind. Imagine that the person in front has completed overtaking, but instead of moving forward, he began to brake, not giving you room to return to your lane. While you are wondering what is going on, he turns left. Who is guilty? You! Since at the beginning of overtaking you were not convinced that at the end of overtaking you will be able to freely return to the previously occupied lane - clause 11.2 of the traffic rules.

Author of the publication

offline 1 day

GarryB83

Comments: 0Publications: 1252Registration: 07/17/2018

Let's talk about double overtaking

The traffic rules contain prohibitions and regulations regarding such a maneuver. It turns out that when there are no prohibitions, then it is allowed.

The current traffic regulations for 2021 do not contain any clauses prohibiting double overtaking. Moreover, regardless of the number of vehicles taking part in such a maneuver.

There is only one condition. Drivers are required to make sure in advance that their actions will not entail any dangerous consequences. That is, the maneuver is safe.

The conclusion about whether a maneuver is safe depends on the consequences. If no accident occurred, then everything was done according to the rules. If an accident occurs, you will have to pay a fine or lose your license.

But clarifications need to be made. According to traffic rules, when performing the action in question, drivers are required to check several points:

there are no cars in the oncoming lane, or they are at a sufficient distance to have time to complete the maneuver;
there is no continuous dividing strip ahead;
there is no sign prohibiting overtaking;
there is no overpass, pedestrian zone, or railway crossing;
the same applies to tunnels, overpasses, dangerous turns and climbs;
at that moment the car behind did not overtake your vehicle;
None of the cars in front activated their left turn signal.

This list fully defines the conditions under which it is and is not possible to overtake and enter the oncoming part of the road. The same applies to the double type of maneuver.

Is it possible to overtake with a train?

What is a “locomotive”? This is overtaking when several drivers rush into the oncoming lane at once, lining up one after another. At the end of the maneuver, they always return to the right side of the road. Since drivers do not always calculate the movement correctly, a serious accident can occur. Safe overtaking is regulated by section 11 of the traffic rules.

According to it, it is prohibited to overtake:

a car in front that is already going around an obstacle;
a car in front signaling a left turn;
the car behind has already started overtaking;
there is no way for all traffic participants to return to the main lane safely;
at controlled intersections, as well as at unregulated ones when driving on a non-main road;
at pedestrian crossings;
at railway crossings (permitted distance is more than 100 m to them);
in tunnels;
on bridges, overpasses, overpasses and under them;
in areas with limited visibility, dangerous turns.

Follow traffic rules, this will help keep your rights and your passengers safe and sound.

Now about overtaking by a train

Here the situation is somewhat different. And it needs to be considered separately.

Let us remember that here we are talking about a maneuver in which your car and at least one other car began to overtake another car, moving one after another. A kind of column.

Plus, there is the concept of overtaking a car that is already overtaking. Imagine the situation. There is a slow car in the lane ahead. You are moving faster. On the left side, the front car began to overtake other vehicles. At this moment, you also pressed the gas, turned left, turning on the turn signal. And now the most important thing. You drive out even further to the left of the car that has started to overtake. And as a result, go around 2 cars at once, one of which also overtakes the other vehicle. It may sound a little confusing, but everything should be clear.

And such a maneuver is considered prohibited.

There are just some nuances. Such an action in the form of a train or a jib is prohibited only by the machine that created the similar effect. That is, there is conditionally the first car that turned on the turn signal and pressed the gas. If all the conditions described above are met, such actions are not considered a violation.

But if there is a line behind this car, and they also turn on the turn signals and press the gas, then the effect of a train is already created. All cars behind you are breaking the rules.

The difficulty is that proving your innocence, even if your vehicle was the first in the created locomotive, is problematic. The only compelling argument will be the video recording from the recorder.

Clause 11.2 of the current rules states that drivers are not allowed to overtake if:

the vehicle in front is overtaking or driving around an obstacle;
the car behind began an overtaking maneuver.

It turns out the following. The inspector saw that your vehicle was in front of the conditional column (train). In theory, it's not your fault. But this is in theory. In practice, the inspector could not see that you did not enter the oncoming lane at the moment when another vehicle had already entered the maneuver.

Taking this into account, it is not at all impossible that a driver who seems to be acting within the rules will not be fined or will not be attempted to have his license revoked.

Is it possible to overtake with a “locomotive” - what the law and the Supreme Court say

In heavy traffic, many drivers resort to single file overtaking - one overtaking vehicle follows another. And such a chain can reach 5-10 cars. This maneuver is explained very simply - there are a lot of continuous roads on Russian roads and very few areas where overtaking can be done.

This is why car owners in Russia most often practice the “steam locomotive” method. However, traffic police inspectors may consider such an action as a malicious offense and try to rip off as much money as possible from drivers. Note that not in all cases such actions of traffic police officers can be justified.

Overtaking . Drivers resort to this action when they have no other option. If there is a slow-moving vehicle ahead and a whole line of cars behind it, according to the rules, overtaking can only be done one at a time. There are many drivers in this stream who want to overtake a car that is barely moving, but there is not enough space on the road for everyone to complete this maneuver. However, on a segment it is quite possible to overtake a “locomotive” of 3-4 cars at once, and 2 conditions must be met:

the road is clearly visible, nothing interferes with the view;
there is no traffic in the oncoming lane.

Situations often arise on the road when participants in a group overtaking are confident that the maneuver is safe, but traffic police officers do not want to agree with this. Skilled officials can deprive a driver who is not competent in the law to deprivation of his license for up to six months. It is indeed possible to lose your right to drive. You can find out about this in paragraph 11.2 of the traffic rules. It states that a driver may not overtake in several situations:

if the car moving in front begins to overtake or goes around an obstacle;
if the car moving in front gives a left turn signal;
if the car moving behind begins to overtake;
if the driver is not confident that he will be able to complete the maneuver without interfering with other road users.

The punishment for these actions is determined in part 4 of article 12.14 of the Code of Administrative Offenses of the Russian Federation. For this, the driver receives an administrative fine of 5,000 rubles or is deprived of his license for six months. However, you can see that in the above paragraph there is not a word about the prohibition of overtaking by a “locomotive”, but traffic police officers have great opportunities to come up with their own rules and punishments for them. Until recently, everyone paid attention to one note - it is forbidden to start a maneuver if the car in front begins to overtake or go around. There were different opinions on this matter, but the Supreme Court put an end to the debate, which stated that overtaking with a “locomotive” is not prohibited by the rules. The main condition for performing a maneuver is that there must be a distance of at least 100 meters between overtaking vehicles so as not to interfere with visibility.

Bottom line. If a traffic police inspector tries to prove that overtaking by a “locomotive” is a violation, provide him with this article and a book with the Rules of the Road. Any driver can perform this maneuver “in single file” if a distance of 100 meters is maintained between the vehicles that are overtaking.

Possible penalties

See also
How to repair or replace the trunk lock on a Lada Kalina

Reminds that there are no penalties for overtaking actions as such. And it doesn’t matter whether it’s a double or a train.

The fact is different. Any such action is often interpreted according to Part 4 of 12.15 of the Administrative Code. And here we are talking about a fine or deprivation of rights for driving into the oncoming part of the road in violation of the rules. There is also an article following it, where the punishment will be much more serious.

As a result, there are 3 possible punishment options. It all depends on the specific situation:

The driver drove into the oncoming lane, violating traffic rules. Interpreted according to Part 4 of Article 12.15. Here, at best, you will have to give 5 thousand rubles to the state treasury. In the worst case, the driver will find himself without a license for a period of 4 to 6 months;
The motorist repeatedly violated the previous rule. In theory, you can pay 5 thousand rubles again. But provided that the violation was recorded using a special camera. But there is a more unpleasant outcome. This is deprivation of a certificate. Only now for 1 year;
The driver was forced to drive onto the oncoming side of the road to avoid the obstacle. And no one will worry that the side of the road on which the driver should eat turned out to be unsuitable for this. Or some other obstacle has arisen. If you left, then be kind enough to pay from 1 to 1.5 thousand rubles.

Now you know about possible liability.

Yes, if the inspector or traffic cameras did not record a violation, then it would be as if it never happened. But this is not a reason to make downright dangerous maneuvers.

What overtaking rules govern the correct maneuver?

In general, a whole section of the traffic rules is responsible for overtaking rules. It specifies the mandatory safety condition for overtaking, its prohibition under certain conditions, as well as the rules of conduct for the overtaken vehicle.

The rules for overtaking are quite self-sufficient, but the punishment is still provided not for overtaking as such, but for driving into the oncoming lane in violation of traffic rules. That is, in principle, overtaking necessarily includes driving into the oncoming lane, but driving into the oncoming lane does not necessarily have to be overtaking, since the latter involves ahead of other vehicles in the oncoming lane.

What are the exceptions?

There are exceptions for this situation. If the driver was moving along a roadway with more than two lanes, and the car in front of him began to overtake, then it is possible to carry out the same maneuver in the left (free) lane.

In this situation, entering the oncoming lane will be excluded, and therefore, since the advance was carried out according to all the rules, it will not be classified as a traffic violation. Moreover, in the rules there are no prohibitions at all that relate to advances in one way or another.